Share

FIRSTonline Banner

Supplementary pension below expectations: the Covip x-ray and the legislator's inertia

Supplementary pension provision has taken on the characteristics of an investment rather than the value of pension savings. The challenge with severance pay in the company

Supplementary pension below expectations: the Covip x-ray and the legislator's inertia

The Supervisory Commission on pension funds (Covip) presented the 2024 report relating to the entire previous year in recent days. Since 2023 marked thirty years since the establishment - with an organic law - of the private funded pension plan (the so-called second pillar) it is appropriate to draw a summary balance sheet on the results and critical issues of the sector compared to the expectations and the role assigned by the legislator who must be blamed for an inertia and disinterest that has lasted for at least twenty years. The only intervention of some importance to be included in this period of time consisted of a considerable increase in the levy on returns which has no longer been modified (it was equal to 11%; it was said that it had to be reduced to 6%; it was increased to 20%).

The accessions

At the end of 2023, at supplementary pension schemes (negotiable or closed-end funds, open-end funds and PIPs, net of simultaneous memberships of multiple forms) joined and were registered is equal to 9,610 million (+4 percent on the previous year). Trading funds recorded an increase of 211.000 positions compared to the end of the previous year (+5,5 percent), for a total that exceeds 4 million. In this regard, the fact that the greatest increases depended on some innovations introduced by collective bargaining (adhesion through collective bargaining) deserves particular attention: in the construction sector (+87.700 positions), as a consequence of the payment of a contribution, although of a modest amount, paid only by the employer; in the public employment fund (+37.600 positions), through membership also through silent consent for newly hired workers. They are then added; 15.700 more positions in the fund intended for the trade, tourism and services sector.

In market pension schemes, there are 109.000 more positions in open funds (+5,9 percent) and 83.000 more in Pip (+2,2 percent); at the end of the year, the total positions outstanding in these forms amounted to 1,950 million and 3,781 million respectively. There is no updated data relating to pre-existing funds which are affected by a positive process of aggregation and reduction.

With respect to employment, 37,6% of employees adhere to complementary forms compared to 23,5% of self-employed workers; the gap widens by considering only the members for whom payments have been made, much less present among the self-employed. As for the geographical area, the participation rate exceeds the national average in the northern regions, especially where the social security offer is integrated with territorial initiatives; lower values ​​and decidedly below the average are recorded, however, in most of the southern regions

Criticalities

For some years, despite a constant increase in writings, the number of those who have stopped paying contributions has been considerable (more than 2 million "dead souls"). Members paying in 2023, excluding "old" PIPs from the calculation, there were 6,7 million, 72,4% of the total. Non-paying members, equal to approximately 2,6 million, were more frequently present in market forms and among self-employed workers. A conspicuous part is also made up of employees enrolled in contractual pension funds, with particular regard to sectors, such as the construction sector, whose basin is characterized by high employment discontinuity

The data referring to individual positions is significant because it is increasingly similar to that of pension funds (the typical product of collective bargaining) especially as among the subscribers of these policies the number of employees prevails, confirming a need for supplementary pension provision (second pillar) which is not adequately met through collective bargaining. In 2022 to "new" PIPs (2,243 million) Twice as many employees participating in the open funds were registered (1,007 million). By adding the last two figures, a notable use of individual use of private pensions was obtained, which remains a confirmed phenomenon.

With reference to the composition of members according to the main socio-demographic characteristics, men make up 61,7% of those enrolled in supplementary pension schemes (72,7% in negotiated funds), confirming the gender gap. In the market forms, women reach 42,6% in open funds and 46,6% in PIPs.

Based on age, the members are predominantly concentrated in the intermediate classes and those closest to retirement (generation gap): 47,8% of members are aged between 35 and 54, 32,9% are at least 55 years old. Although still at lower percentages than the other groups, in recent years the weight of the youngest component (up to 34 years) on the total number of members has nevertheless grown, going from 17,6% in 2019 to 19,3% in 2023. In fact, among the new members, the share of tax dependent subjects is growing, whose registration is mainly directed in favor of market forms. This reflects family decisions to open a social security position for their children with a view to subsequently providing them with independent payments once they enter the world of work.

The different involvement in the labor market contributes to a large part of the explanation the differences in participation in complementary pensions from a gender and age group perspective. Compared to the workforce, participation in complementary pensions increases with age: between 15 and 34 years it stands at 27,4%, rising to 32,8% in the range between 35 and 44 years, at 36 % in the 45-54 class and finally 45% between 55 and 64 years. Compared to five years earlier, the participation rate of the younger class grew by 6 percentage points and that of the other groups by 3,5-4 percentage points.

The resources allocated to performance

The resources allocated to services amounted to 222,6 billion euros, up 8,2%, compared to 205,6 billion at the end of 2022. Approximately three-fifths of the increase was due to the improvement in the prices of the securities in the portfolio; the rest was due to contribution flows net of expenditure. Net assets were 67,9 billion euros in trading funds, increased by 11,1% compared to the end of the previous year; it stood at 32,6 billion in open funds and 49,9 billion in PIPs, respectively, 16,3% and 9,8% more compared to the end of 2022. During 2023 the amount of contributions collected from negotiated funds, open-ended funds and PIPs amounted to 14,7 billion euros, an increase of 5,7% over 2022. The increase was 7,7% in negotiated funds and 7,4% in open funds, while it was lower in PIPs (2,3%)

The negotiated funds held 30,2% of the total resources, the open funds 14,5% and the PIPs 25,3%; the weight of pre-existing funds, equal to the remaining 30% of the total, for the first time this year was not prevalent compared to that of negotiated funds. The contributions collected during the year amounted to 19,2 billion euros (+5,2% compared to 2022), growing in all complementary pension forms: 6,5 billion euros were collected in the negotiated funds (+7,7 .3,1%); in open funds 7,4 billion (+5,1%), in "new" PIPs 2,3 billion euros (+4,3%); 3,8 billion euros flowed into pre-existing funds (+15,8%). 961 billion euros of contributions flowed into the positions of employees, an increase of XNUMX million compared to the previous year. Of these, 7,8 billion euros concern severance pay shares; the contributions paid by workers and employers are equal to 5 and 2,9 billion euros respectively. For self-employed workers, payments of 1,7 billion euros were received, 29 million more than in 2022.

Advances and redemptions

The advances and redemptions which intervene to reduce the contribution amount confirm that the complementary pension has taken on the characteristics of an investment rather than the value of pension savings. The advances (which constitute a reason for competition with severance pay and which do not facilitate the role of social security finance) they amounted to 2,3 billion, of which 939 million in negotiated funds and 768 million in pre-existing ones. Among the reasons, the purchase or renovation of the first home stands out, with disbursements of 1,1 billion euros and an average amount of 30 thousand euros and that for reasons not attributable to a specific case, 1,1 billion in total for an average amount of 8,4 thousand euros.

For ransoms, 2 billion euros in total, most of which were concentrated in negotiated funds with 850 million and in pre-existing funds with 677 million. The largest share of ransoms is made up of total ones: 1,6 billion euros for an average amount of 15.800 euros. Advance temporary supplementary annuities (“Rita”) increased: the overall disbursement was 1,6 billion euros (357 million more than in 2021), for an average amount of 57 thousand euros; the majority of the disbursements, 1,4 billion euros (306 million more than in 2021), were concentrated in pre-existing funds. 28.800 positions were affected by "Rita" disbursements, up compared to 22.500 the previous year; of these, 22.200 concerned the entire amount accumulated.

In 2023, expenditure for social security management amounted to a total of 11,6 billion euros. Pension benefits were paid in capital for 4,5 billion euros and in annuities for 401 million euros. Although the resources allocated to services correspond to 10,8% of GDP and 4% of the financial assets of Italian families, supplementary social security rather than playing the role of a ''second private pillar'' and of a collective/contractual nature, can be configured as a form of financial investment, sufficiently guaranteed and tax-advantaged, which also allows you to have available (as a contribution and with the related foreseen possibility of larger advances) a disbursement ( the severance pay) during and not at the end of the employment relationship, rather than a benefit that plays a complementary role to the mandatory treatment.

Yields

As for returns, in 2023 all types of pension schemes and sectors recorded positive results on average, with higher values ​​for managements with greater equity exposure. For the equity sectors, average returns of 10% are found in trading funds, 11,3% in open-end funds and 11,4% in PIPs. In the balanced lines the results are on average equal to 6,9% in trading funds, 8,3 in open funds and 7,1 in PIPs; the yields of the bond and guaranteed sectors are lower.

Evaluating the returns over time horizons more consistent with the purposes of pension savings, in the last ten years (from the beginning of 2014 to the end of 2023) the average compound annual returns of the lines with a higher equity content are around 4-4,5 percent per cent. all types of pension forms; for balanced lines, average returns are between 2 and 3 percent. The guaranteed and bond lines, on the other hand, show average returns close to zero or slightly higher; the separate management of branch I of the PIPs, which account for the assets at historical cost and not at market value, obtain a return of 1,8%. Basically the performance of pension schemes has withstood and sometimes overcome the challenge with severance pay whose revaluation by law, during the same period, was found to be equal to 2,4%. All the equity sectors and also a good part of the balanced ones show higher returns than the others and the severance pay. For each type of investment line, the trading funds show overall a lower dispersion of the returns of the individual sectors than that recorded by open-end and Pip funds.
Investment allocation

Pension fund investments (excluding mathematical reserves at insurance companies and internal pension funds of institutions and companies) are mainly allocated, for 56% of the total, in government bonds (14,1% are Italian public debt securities) and other debt securities. Capital securities are equal to 21,4% of the total while UCITS shares are 15,8% of the total. Deposits stand at 5%; real estate investments, directly and indirectly, amounted to 1,8% of the total.

Overall, the value of pension fund investments in the Italian economy (government bonds, securities issued by entities resident in Italy and real estate) is 36,6 billion euros, equal to 19,4% of the total compared to 20,8% in 2022 (35,5 billion euros). From time to time, dirigiste appetites emerge, in the sense of finding tools to direct these resources to national purposes. It is a temptation to be avoided if you want to safeguard the sector and the reserve pensions.

The challenge with severance pay in the company

The severance pay is the main source of financing of the contributory position, but the main part of the severance pay accrues from time to time and remains available to the company. Itineraries social security has demonstrated how this option is less convenient for the worker even in the face of the revaluation by law not foreseen in the case of destination to a form of private social security. He writes Leo Campagna that the advantages of joining a pension fund are many, particularly in the tax field. For workers who have chosen the destination of the severance pay in the category pension fund there is first of all the possibility of deducting voluntary contributions with savings based on the income bracket. But there's even more. Choosing the pension fund instead of leaving the TFR with the company gives the worker the possibility of accessing another possible plus: the payment of the employer's contribution to the complementary pension form, which is not due to the employee who opts for the TFR in the company.

In this regard, the example that is reported every year in the balance sheet of Fonchim, the pension fund for workers in the chemical and pharmaceutical sector, is enlightening, regarding the comparison between the first member and his hypothetical twin who decided not to register. The sector used is Stability, the one with the longest operating history and by far the most significant in terms of resources managed, therefore particularly significant. Well, the example shows how, from a long-term perspective, the pension fund's investment has so far managed to fulfill its institutional task of increase the capital of members with a view to retirement.

In particular, from 14 March 1997 to 31 December 2023, with the member's contribution being equal (19.473 euros), severance pay (89.736 euros) and voluntary contribution (20.942 euros), in the case of the worker who has chosen the Stability Section, the company's contribution was also added (34.181 euros). The return is 55.186 euros for the participating worker compared to 26.996 euros for the twin who did not join the fund. Overall, the member of the Stability sector would have accrued 219.518 euros, i.e. almost 40% more than the 157.147 euros of the non-member worker.

comments