Share

FIRSTonline Banner

Galli: "It is possible to avoid a recession, but politics must not go crazy"

“The ECB will raise rates without causing the economy to fall, but it is unlikely that it will find a solution for spreads. The State must do a lot, but not invade the space of private individuals".

Galli: "It is possible to avoid a recession, but politics must not go crazy"

Very high inflation, the likes of which has not been seen for almost thirty years, is eroding disposable income and therefore it is probable that in the autumn we will see a further slowdown in Western economies. And yet both the Fed and the ECB have expressed their intention to proceed gradually towards an increase in interest rates and a reduction in the liquidity of the system, while fiscal policies, also thanks to the European funds of the Next Generation EU, should remain slightly expansionary, and this should avoid a full-blown recession. Provided that the conflict generated by the Russian invasion of Ukraine does not evolve catastrophically. It will certainly have effects on energy prices, and gas prices in particular, but otherwise it could have limited effects. This, in a nutshell, is the opinion of Giampaolo Galli, former director general of Confindustria and ANIA, who currently works alongside Carlo Cottarelli at the Catholic University of Milan.

Very difficult situation. Uncertainty aggravates consumer and investor prospects. To try to unravel the skein, let's begin by clarifying the characteristics of this inflationary wave and therefore by focusing on the possible medicines to adopt.

«In general, it can be said that the large liquidity created by central banks for a good part of the previous decade, and which then even accelerated during COVID in 2020 also due to very expansive fiscal policies, caused a very rapid economic recovery in 2021 which has collided with supply bottlenecks, due both to the lack of investment in the energy sector and in many infrastructures, and with a policy, also desired by governments, first and foremost the Trump presidency, aimed at a redefinition of globalisation. The imposition of duties and other obstacles to free trade have led many companies to look for new supply chains, to repatriate some products, to look for reliable countries with which to establish stable supply agreements. All of this takes time and comes with costs. So the supply of products has not been able to satisfy the impetuous return of demand and consequently prices have entered tensions».

“Inflation started well before the war in Ukraine”

But isn't the main cause of inflation in energy products and in particular in the increase in the price of gas and other raw materials?

«The increases in the prices of raw materials started several months before the outbreak of the war, on February 24th. Indeed, if we look at the prices of some raw materials, we see that most of the increases occurred last year. Copper, for example, has fallen by 24% since February 23 while it has risen by 60% compared to January 2020, that is, before the explosion of the health emergency. The trend for aluminum is similar, while tin has risen by 161% compared to before the pandemic but has fallen by 50% since February of this year. Lumber is up 200% from 2020, but is down 50% in recent months from its highs. Oil also went up a lot towards the end of last year and then remained more or less stable around $100. Gas is a different matter, which is more affected by European dependence on Russia. Prices rose before the war from $20 to $230 before returning to around $90. In recent days, with Putin's threat to completely cut off supplies to Europe, the price has shot up to over $160. This is to clarify that the price run began well before the war broke out and that our inflation has very little to do with our sanctions on Russia or their counter-sanctions. The responsibilities must be traced back to the imposition of tariffs on China and also on Europe by Trump".

It is therefore clear that since we are dealing with a supply crisis (at least in Europe), monetary policy alone cannot solve all the problems. Investments will have to be made to eliminate bottlenecks, restore a certain fluidity to world trade, keep inflation under control.

«In the energy sector, private individuals do not have much desire to increase their investments, given that they have been told by all governments that within twenty years or so all fossil fuels must be banned to bring climate change under control. So it will be the states that will have to make the appropriate investments to avoid running out of energy and therefore blocking production in industrialized countries. For monetary policy it is essential to gradually return to a more "normal" interest rate structure. Even today the rate on bank deposits with the ECB is minus 0,50% and will soon drop to minus 0,25%, a small change. Rates on securities have also increased slightly but in real terms, ie taking into account inflation which is around 8%, they are still very low. As experienced central bankers have pointed out, in the past when the Fed wanted to implement a soft landing from inflation, i.e. when it wanted to cause an economic slowdown, but not a recession: it has always succeeded, except in the 80s, when Paul Volker wanted to quickly block the price increases that had been going on for too many years and had caused fatigue and disorientation in public opinion. We are not in that situation today. Inflation is a recent phenomenon, almost unknown to the new generations, so public opinion would not understand too harsh a squeeze by central banks".

How the ECB can contain the spread gap

Above all, the ECB is grappling with a further problem, namely that of avoiding an excessive gap in the spread between countries, a gap which if too accentuated could lead to a more general crisis of the effectiveness of monetary policy and, ultimately, of the Euro. It is not a new problem that interests Italy above all at the moment.

"It's a complex problem. Lagarde pledged to present a plan to prevent the difference in rates between the various countries from widening dramatically. But to do so, it would be necessary to buy that country's bonds without limits, which is contrary to the statute of the ECB, goes against the intention of monetary policy to adopt a more restrictive posture and above all could involve a real transfer of money from some countries to others, which must be decided only by a political body and not by the Central Bank. Technically, as the president of the Bundesbank pointed out, it is not easy to distinguish between unjustified increases in spreads, i.e. those based on operators' expectations which, if left to themselves, tend to come true, and differentials due to the fundamentals of the respective economies. The Governor of the Bank of Italy has attempted this operation setting the differential of the Italian spread at 150-200 points due to the fundamentals of our economy. And for the moment the market has believed in it».

But now everyone expects some convincing proposals to come out of the ECB's hat to keep speculation at bay and avoid excessive widening of the Italian spread. Recently two economists, Ignazio Angeloni and Daniel Gros, in an article on Sun 24 Hours, they argued that the tool to block the Italy risk already exists, and it is the precautionary line of the MES.

«Apart from the fact that the ESM is seen as smoke and mirrors by many Italian politicians, we need to see if it is really possible to activate this tool which requires commitments from the countries that request it. However, it will always be necessary to pass through the board of the ESM, in which the representatives of the European governments sit, and therefore a decision of this kind in any case passes through political scrutiny, as indeed it must be. In short, it is necessary to establish whether a country with fundamentals in order is attacked by speculation and therefore needs temporary liquidity support, or if it is in a position of structural crisis and therefore needs a real bailout. In the latter case it is a question of transferring wealth from one country to another and this must pass through an eminently political decision. In short, the ECB will probably make a proposal similar to that of the precautionary line, but which however will require conditionalities which in our country it will have to adhere to, in case it wants to activate the shield, such as OMT, i.e. an unlimited intervention by the European Central Bank in support of its public debt securities».

So let's go back to the problem that our public debt and the management of our budget is above all a problem of internal economic policy choices. Now with the increase in inflation the debt/GDP ratio should improve, provided, of course, that the hoards that are formed thanks to the increase in revenues due to the rise in prices, are not immediately used to increase public expenditure.

«I note that most of the parties are making proposals for new expenses (more pensions, more welfare, more money for local authorities) but no one indicates how to find the resources or how to reduce current expenses, many of which should be revisited to put some limits. For example, we are now refinancing the Municipality of Naples, but nobody quite understands whether the debts have accumulated due to errors by the previous Neapolitan administrators or due to an erroneous state policy towards the municipalities. So many bonuses are distributed in spades, while it would certainly be better to concentrate them on the neediest segments of the population. The same goes for businesses where incentives are not always effective to stimulate innovation and therefore the growth of the businesses themselves. The Italian parties create uncertainty which has repercussions on the markets by increasing the risk in Italy».

Even Draghi has repeatedly said that the only possible recipe for our country, caught in the grip of public debt, is higher growth. And yet given the difficulty encountered by reforms and the continuing emergency in which the country is forced to act, it does not seem to me that we have taken a sure path towards greater growth.

«A part of our companies, especially manufacturing, has been able to innovate and has managed to maintain its share of international trade over the last decade despite the arrival of emerging countries and in particular of China. On the other hand, we are unable to increase the efficiency of the public machine. Minister Brunetta himself had to renounce his 2009 reform which included an assessment of professionalism and therefore merit in the career advancement of civil servants. Instead we will continue to move forward by seniority, and in the upper levels the appearance in consortia or political clans will be worth more and more. Even the magistrates rebel against that small innovation represented by the "evaluation file" launched by the Cartabia reform, preferring to entrust one's career to seniority or, for top positions, to the methods well described by the former magistrate Palamara».

“Giuliano Amato too optimistic about the role of the state”

In a recent essay, Giuliano Amato offers a "welcome back" to the state, called to do many fundamental things to allow us to grow, and which, in his opinion, has purified itself of the old vices of intriguing politics.

«I don't think our system already has the antibodies to avoid the troubles of the past. There are still too many discretionary inventions and therefore it is normal for entrepreneurs to queue in front of the politicians' rooms to get a share. Many studies have made it clear that politically funded firms generally make good short-term profits but innovate less than the others and therefore end up growing less. In reality, the State must keep away from the direct or indirect management of companies, while it should concentrate on general policies such as, for example, those indicated by the EU which also concern digitization and environmental remediation. Then there is education, research and, especially these days, security. So many things to do well and with foresight, helping the market without interfering in management decisions».

comments