Share

FIRSTonline Banner

Reverse charge and telematic invoicing: the recipe of the Nens Foundation against tax evasion

A series of changes in the VAT rules as the basis of a broad maneuver to recover revenue from tax evasion, which could allow for a significant reduction of tax levels, up to 59 billion euros a year: this is the recipe elaborated by the Nens Foundation – The extension of the reverse charge is the basis of the interventions.

Reverse charge and telematic invoicing: the recipe of the Nens Foundation against tax evasion

A series of interventions in the VAT rules as the basis of a broad maneuver to recover revenue from tax evasion, which could allow for a significant reduction, up to 59 billion euros a year, of the levels of taxation. This is the recipe elaborated by the Nens Foundation. At the basis of the interventions, the extension of the reverse charge.

The figures involved are substantial: according to a study by the Nens Foundation (new economy, new society), animated by Pierluigi Bersani and Vincenzo Visco, in the VAT sector alone, tax evasion would amount to around 40 billion euros a year, if one compares the theoretical VAT with the declared VAT using national accounts data. Not only that, but the numerous forms of tax evasion have their effects also on the taxable bases of Irap and direct taxes. An effective action to combat VAT evasion, therefore, could produce a recovery of overall revenue, also considering other taxes, which the Nens Foundation estimates at almost 59 billion euros a year. An income recovery of this size, the study by the Nens Foundation states, would paradoxically risk having a negative impact on the national economy, if it were not accompanied by the immediate redistribution of the recovered taxes, with an equally drastic reduction in the fiscal, to give new life to the country's economic and social system.

The phenomenon of tax evasion is too complex and profound to be eradicated exclusively with control and assessment activities, but requires a more articulated contrast strategy. Tax evasion must be prevented, rather than fought, first of all by acting on the rules of the game through legislative and procedural measures, which interfere in a targeted way with the very mechanisms of evasion; as well as using technological tools that make it more difficult to implement and easier to identify, without this entailing any burden for those who already regularly pay taxes. 

The Nens Foundation indicates which are the main channels through which tax evasion takes place: the omitted declaration of VAT on consumption, the omitted declaration of invoiced intermediate supplies, the omitted invoicing/declaration of intermediate supplies of goods non-deductibles, false invoicing, the instrumental use of the rates. Here, then, what would be the useful measures to contrast these phenomena and obtain the greatest revenue considered recoverable.

Adoption of a single VAT rate. The single rate can be established in such a way as to leave the overall tax burden unchanged, but with the advantage of recovering the evasion due to the instrumental use of the rates. An intermediate way would consist in leaving the reduced rate in force only for food products or main residences.

Application of the ordinary rate to intermediate exchanges. Since the percentage of evasion on sales for final consumption is much higher than that on intermediate exchanges, by shifting taxation towards the latter, by raising the intermediate rate, a reduction in overall evasion is obtained. Alternatively, the "analytical base by base" method could be applied to sales to the final consumption of the trade; the method is already used in our legal system, albeit limited to a few specific cases (e.g. antique goods and travel packages). In addition to revenue recovery, this measure would lead to a reduction in credits and the elimination of false horizontal compensations.

Introduction of the electronic receipt. The electronic transmission to the tax authorities of the amounts relating to the sales for which the tax receipt is issued should lead to an increase in the VAT declared.

Payment by electronic card for professional services. The objective is similar to that of electronic receipts: to ensure that the amounts collected against the receipts issued are all declared by the professionals. The mechanism could work like this: the bank transfers the payments made by electronic card to a special current account in the professional's name (as happens in commerce for payments via POS; the account is linked to an "electronic service card" with which the trader is required to simulate payment when the customer pays with other means (cash, check, bank transfer); in this case the bank records the payment, without making any payment (income = outgoing); the bank provides a payment receipt (the receipt issued by the POS), which becomes an integral part of the tax receipt issued by the professional.

Application of the "reverse charge" to intermediate operations. In this case the taxable transaction is the purchase, rather than the sale: the buyer issues the invoice and the VAT due to the State is charged. The recovery of revenue is the result of two different factors: the disappearance of intermediate evasion, due to the fact that VAT no longer circulates; the increase in sales declared to keep the profit margin high, as it is no longer possible to alter it with the omitted declaration of purchases. But above all, the reverse charge regime would produce positive effects on sales for final consumption. The omitted declaration of part of the self-invoiced purchases, in order to expose a more credible profit margin, would be officially ascertainable starting from the "Customer and supplier lists".

In order to be able to apply the reverse charge in a generalized way, however, the authorization of the EU is needed, for which Germany has already submitted a similar request. This circumstance could lead to the need to initially limit the application of the new regime only to some specific sectors, such as the retail and wholesale trade.

Introduction of telematic billing. It would produce results similar to the reverse charge, albeit to a lesser extent. It would be a question of introducing the invoicing obligation for intermediate operations through the use of a computerized procedure, which envisages the electronic transmission to the tax authorities of the information contained in the invoices, in order to avoid the omitted declaration of intermediate operations, both sale as in purchase.

Direct crediting of the VAT charged to the PA to the state budget. It would be a question of having the public administrations pay the VAT due for purchases and investments directly on a specific revenue item of the state budget rather than to their suppliers. Consequently, the obligation for suppliers to advance (on an accrual basis) the VAT not yet collected (on a cash basis) would disappear and all the facilitation rules introduced to defer payment at the time of payment could be cancelled.

According to the Nens Foundation, if fully implemented these measures could increase VAT revenue, when fully operational, by around 27 billion euros. However, they would also have positive consequences on the revenue from direct taxes and Irap, calculated at a further 32 billion in Irpef, Ires and Irap revenue, when fully operational. The Nens Foundation notes, however, that certain authorizations from the European Union are required for the application of these innovations.

comments