Share

FIRSTonline Banner

The CGIL has been wavering in the face of referendums: from the consultation on monarchy and republic to that on justice, the style has not always been the same.

During the referendum, the CGIL took an open stance, but this has not always been the case: here is how the largest Italian union has behaved during the referendum consultations from 1946 to today and what the effects are.

The CGIL has been wavering in the face of referendums: from the consultation on monarchy and republic to that on justice, the style has not always been the same.

In the successful novel by Alexander Dumas père, the Three Musketeers were four: Athos, Porthos, Aramis; to them is added D'Artagnan. Even the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse of the Wide Field There are actually five in the making: Elly Schlein, Giuseppe Conte, Angelo Bonelli, Nicola Fratoianni and… Maurizio Landini. LaCGIL – the most important Italian trade union – does not limit itself to "doing politics" (as is normal to happen, without limitations, on issues that concern the economy, work and fiscal and welfare policies) but is increasingly characterised as a subject in transition towards an unprecedented form of party. And in this way he distorts his representative function, as it is the protagonist of a political offering juxtaposed to that of the parties. A citizen, in a democratic and open society, has several options for participating in public life: the political party offers him an ideology, a vision and a program; theunion assures him protection in its identity as a worker, with an openness that embraces other general issues. However, if the offering is the same, the articulation of a pluralistic society is lacking, and the Soviet model is repeated—perhaps in a sixteenth-century fashion—where the party and the union pursued the same objectives. 

CGIL and its position on the referendum on justice

Let's take the case of the referendum on justice: the natural interlocutor of citizens would be the party or in any case politics in the strict sense; workers too, as citizens, have the interest of being able to count on an independent and autonomous judiciary, but they do not need it either the union to which they are registered, concentrate their efforts on this battle, perhaps neglecting functions and initiatives specific to their role. 

At the end of the day, as Roberto Mania and Andrea Garnero wrote in the essay ''The Salary Question'' (Egea editrice): when the confederate union gets involved in politics Strictly speaking, it operates within the same sphere as political parties, challenging them, allying with them, supporting them, and taking action that does little to help the more strictly trade union activity that continues to be carried out by the trade unions, which sign contracts, "often late," but constitute another type of union, an expression of tradition and the reasons why workers join. 

If we look at the experiences that have characterised the development of that instrument of direct democracy which is precisely the referendum, only in the institutional consultation of the June 2, 1946, the CGIL (then united and led by Giuseppe Di Vittorio) openly supported the Republic. The union saw regime change as the opportunity to build a new Italy, founded on workers' rights and democracy, definitively overcoming the legacy of fascism and the monarchy that had supported it. But that union had been created through an agreement of the anti-fascist mass parties. Moreover, it is one thing to give voting instructions to one's members and citizens, while it is another matter to become direct protagonists of an electoral campaign as happened during the referendum on justice. 

In the past the CGIL has never gone beyond an appeal

In referendum on work Last year, the CGIL was discussing provisions pertaining to its function, although the recourse to an abrogative referendum seemed strange. Looking back at the consultations that changed the country's history, the Confederation (now led by Landini) has never gone beyond an appeal and an indication to vote. In referendum on divorce In 1974, the CGIL framed the fight to defend the law not only as a matter of civility, aimed at recognizing people's freedom to defend their individual choices (a need also felt by the so-called Catholic Democrats, including many CISL unionists); but, precisely for these reasons, it also saw a social issue that a union could not ignore. However, in Piazza del Popolo, the closing rally of the election campaign was held by all the leaders of the secular parties, from Liberals to Communists. Lama was not on stage. 

In the case of referendum on the sliding scale In 1985, the Confederazione di Corso d'Italia did not take an official position, even though its activists fought on opposing sides in the referendum battle, sometimes in defense of, and sometimes for, the repeal of that law. Indeed, the year before, during the conversion process of the February 14 decree, all hell broke loose, but the Communist component of the CGIL never wanted to use its majority in the governing bodies to call strikes or organize demonstrations. The task was delegated to a group of councils of delegates from major companies, so as not to jeopardize—as happened in 1948 after the assassination attempt on Palmiro Togliatti—the organization's unity. 

With Landini, the CGIL returns to activism

Under the direction of Maurizio Landini the CGIL has gone back decades: to activism, to one-way pacifism. We have witnessed a pro-Pal escalation that is about to be undermined by increasingly merciless winds of war. But the mystification of reality is becoming increasingly difficult and risky. If in the last century, for many decades it was easy to identify the USSR with the cause of peace, accepting its rhetoric (with the one-way Partisans of Peace) according to which the leading nation of socialism was forced to arm itself to defend itself from imperialism, today the traveling companions are increasingly unpresentable, so much so that the masses can mobilize not out of solidarity with them but out of the resurgence of an atavistic hatred towards what the West represents. The reemergence of old vices leads the CGIL outside the scope of trade unionism traditional confederal and place it, together with the old tool of the Anpi, in thearea of ​​radical trade unionism Basically, it suffers from all the exanthematic diseases of corporatism in its politics of demands and of maximalism on broader economic, social, and political issues. In a few hours, the citizens' response will tell us whether this approach is working. 

comments