About one thing Enrico Letta is right and that is on the fact that the Democratic Party, after the electoral defeat, suffers from a severe identity crisis. In other words, he struggles to tell the country, simply and clearly, what he intends to do and with whom he plans to do it. But, above all, it's hard to say what exactly the PD is. From the DC, from the PCI and PSI the Italians knew everything: they knew their identity and their programmes. Even gods 5 Stars we know who they are (populists) and what they want (subsidies, subsidies and more subsidies). Of the PD, however, no. It is only known that they are leftist Democrats. Too little to define a Party. As Paolo Cirino Pomicino astutely observed, "left democrats" is little more than a road sign that says nothing about its political culture (socialist? liberal? popular?) nor about its constituency (working classes? productive middle classes? intermediate ones The marginalized?) Today's PD is so indefinite that it could be everything and its opposite, depending on the circumstances and who governs it pro tempore. In these conditions, the PD can be taken over by anyone, even by whom, how Elly Schleinhe's not even signed up.
Democratic Party and the risk of entrusting the fate of the left to the 5 Stars
To date, there are two potential consortiums vying to conquer it: there is that of the 5 Stars, sponsored externally by D'Alema and Bersani and supported internally by Bettini, Orlando, Boccia and many others. And there is that of mayors, administrators and reformists headed (if he dissolves the reserve) by the Governor of Emilia, Stefano Bonaccini. If the first of these prevails two roped parties in a short space of time, a grouping similar to the one created in France by Mélenchon (la France insoumise) within which the PD would end up like the French PS, that is, it would disappear. If, on the other hand, the consortium of administrators and reformists prevailed, then perhaps the PD could resume dialogue with the Strength centrist liberals and reformists to give life to a credible centre-left line-up.
The PD could learn from the SPD
In this case, the PD could legitimately aspire to the role that the SPD which, it is said for the benefit of the forgetful of the PD, in order to govern has not allied itself with the extreme left of the Lefties (the German counterpart of Fratoianni) but with the liberals and with the German greens which have nothing to do with Bonelli's greens. They would be two antithetical outcomes that would however have one thing in common: that of clarifying once and for all the political position of the PD. In the camp of populists and antagonists the former, in that of reformists the latter. End of ambiguity.
The long eclipse of the left: Occhetto preferred to venture towards nowhere
Ambiguity, in addition to being one of the worst forms of intellectual dishonesty, has always been a harbinger of defeats in politics. He knows something Achille Occhetto that way back in 1989, in the aftermath of the Fall of the Berlin Wall and the collapse of communism, not knowing (and not wanting) to choose between the path social democratic, which was the most suitable for the PCI, and that antagonistic, which was the furthest from the true nature of the PCI, chose not to choose. And, instead of facing the difficult problems that those epochal events posed for the entire left, she preferred to raise the sails and sail towards unknown shores, beyond social democracy and beyond capitalism, in the vain search for a non-existent third way. The psychodrama (actually a true historical tragedy) of the long and surreal debate on the name of the new "thing" that was supposed to replace the PCI finally resulted in the creation of a hybrid, the "Democratic Party of the Left”, whose name deliberately made no reference to the tradition of Italian and European socialism or to the world of work. A party neither Social Democrat nor Labor which was then soundly defeated by Berlusconi in the '94 elections.
The hatred for social democracy (and for Craxi) was such in the PCI that Occhetto's leadership group, rather than defining itself social democrats in order to thus be able to contribute to the reunification of the forces of the Italian socialism, a reunification that the collapse of communism made possible, preferred to venture towards nowhere, adopting a name which, as already mentioned, Pomicino would later say reminded him of a road sign rather than a political identity.
The crisis of the left has deep roots
He did not even remedy this capital error, which is one of the causes of the failure to create a great social democratic force in Italy Veltroni with his PD. The ambiguity about the political and cultural identity of the party worsened if possible. Even so crowded in his Pantheon, the greats of Italian socialist reformism such as Turati, Nipple o Saragat, nor those communists who were most committed to socialist unity such as By Vittorio e George Amendola nor did the Catholic reformists like Don Sturzo e De Gasperi. The two great reference figures of the PD were Enrico Berlinguer e Dossetti, a communist and a Christian Democrat, two great and charismatic figures neither of which, however, to be honest, would have accepted to be defined as a reformist. The bitter truth is that the reformist culture of a socialist, liberal and Catholic matrix has never been the majority in the Italian left, let alone in the PD. And this is the real reason why the Democratic Party in times of crisis such as the one we are going through is so dangerously exposed to the suggestions of populism, antagonism and fanatical environmentalism.
The PD chooses an identity or is destined to wear out
If Letta and the reformists really don't want the PD to be overwhelmed by this wave, then they must oppose it loud and clear. They must defend the roots of the Democratic Party in the world of work and its link with the great emancipatory tradition of socialism and popular Catholicism and this battle would be all the more effective and clarifying if the congress decided to add the adjective "democratic" in the name of the party ” the term “social”: social democratic. It would not be the last of many metamorphosis but the definitive clarification of its true nature, the end of a misunderstanding.
