Woe betide anyone who toasts the great compromise that is taking shape these days. The experts, the real ones and especially those less entangled in LOBBY and in political games, they are already preparing the barrage. The idea of pleasing everyone by allowing the production and sale in Europe of the theoretically cleanest cars between those halfway between electric and thermal, that is, the “plug-in” hybrids and those equipped with a small thermal engine for “emergency” charging (range extender), could turn out to be a real mess.
The idea, born from politicians and placed on the table of the European Commission, is making its way. With three promises apparently decisive. The first, essential because it reassures the industry: the European car will be able to survive and perhaps prosper further, with a less tiring transition towards the plug-in hybrid or “range extender” than the total revolution towards pure electric. In fact, it will be possible to increase the production of European models that already exist, avoiding subservience to the already overflowing production of Chinese electric vehicles now faced only by the Tesla of the controversial Elon Musk, the director of the new global political-economic-industrial conjunction.
Second promise, providential to gather consensus: citizens would be assured a softer passage and less traumatic towards the complete electrification of mobility. And here is the third promise, crucial because it must make the fundamental assumption credible: by doing so, the objectives that the new mobility will be able to give to green policies would still be safeguarded.
Will it work? The fears are more than justified. The three promises, as is widely understood, are credible only if they are fully and simultaneously realized: industry is saved, citizens are protected, the environment is helped. Good, that is, bad. Because the third promise, the crucial one, that is, environmental protection, is the one that risks collapsing starting today.
The Great Deception of Approval Cycles
Does the “plug-in” or “range extender” car pollute less than the most recent internal combustion engines? That is not certain. And everything that surrounds the claims that are circulating, evidently with a bit of superficiality, if not deception, is not true. The plug-in can actually pollute less, coming close (not much) to the environmental parameters of the electric engine, whose green virtues should also be correlated to the generation type of the electricity used to recharge them. But it must be carefully managed, dedication and commitment. Otherwise risks polluting (and cost, also in terms of running costs) more not only than "full hybrid" cars, those that self-recharge and do everything by themselves, but also than a petrol car and even more so than a latest generation diesel, now criminalised by everyone with very little justification and many conspicuous flaws in ours mobility policies and the environment.
The diagnoses and accusations of the real experts
Suspicions? Crude diagnoses, rather. As some authoritative reports, curiously little considered, testify. We cite two. That of the German researchers of Fraunhofer institutes for System and Innovation Research in Karlsruhe and the periodically updated but little publicised one, the result of the monitoring started since 2021 by the same European Commission. Two indictments, which are largely convergent in their results and related messages: plug-in hybrid cars are far from keeping their promises, in their real capabilities but, even more importantly, in the results of their actual use.
A diagnosis that comes from the conjunction of two factors. The first: even if used to the maximum of their green capacity, recharging the batteries whenever possible, at least once a day ensuring a “pure” electric ride between 50 and 100 km and keeping a light foot to maximize hybrid capacity for the rest of the journey, plug-in they consume much more than they promise. Second factor, determining the bad result: plug-ins are instead used very badly. Private individuals who physically own them and who pay for the fuel in full (petrol and diesel, or even electricity to recharge) are rather undisciplined, recharge little, use too much with the internal combustion engine. But the real axe on green hopes comes from drivers of company fleets, who in many cases enjoy the fuel or electric recharges paid for by the company.
In the first case (direct owners) we are insufficiency, in the second (company cars) disaster. The German researchers, who analyzed the data produced by over 9 thousand plug-in cars throughout Europe, launch accusations in rapid succession: even the plug-in models approved according to the new Wlpt cycle (which was supposed to ensure more rigorous criteria on actual consumption) vary from three times compared to those approved up to even five times for company cars. The reason is easy to explain.
The reasons for the deception? Even in behaviors
Company car users? Wasteful and undisciplined as ever, the data says. Not only are the actual consumption of a plug-in car, even if used at its best, higher than advertised, but they even manage to cancel any advantage: there are many people who, not having to pay for fuel, carefully avoid the small additional inconvenience of electric charging, driving almost always or even always with the internal combustion engine.
A behavioral defect that adds to the intrinsic problem of plug-ins, which as many know but evidently not all, when they run with the internal combustion engine they consume more compared to a corresponding car with only a combustion engine, lighter because it does not have to "transport" the electric engine and its battery, therefore more efficient than a plug-in that is not used correctly. Result: in the case of company cars "the real fuel consumption for plug-in hybrids - accuse the German researchers - oscillates between 7,6 and 8,4 liters per 100 kilometers" against "official" consumption of around 1,6 - 1,7 liters, laughable as they are incredible. Much worse than any "full hybrid", much worse than a good diesel, worse than many petrol-only engines.
A veil of silence is being drawn over the few car models equipped with a “power extender”, that is, a thermal engine that is still present, called upon to recharge the batteries of cars that are very similar to fully electric ones when needed. A solution that is revealing all its advantages contradictions: almost useless, harmful to efficiency because it weighs down a substantially electric vehicle. In all of this, the “full hybrid” cars are substantially safe, which as has been widely verified still offer good advantages with their system for recovering energy that would otherwise be wasted.
The course correction between promises and uncertainties
The data collected by the European Commission are not very different, and it promises at the very least to quickly and officially "clarify" the situation by once again modifying ("by 2025", it was announced last year) the criteria for the cycles of approval of all cars: electric, hybrid, plug-in hybrid and thermal, as long as the latter can be born and live.
The messages we should draw from all this would seem unequivocal. The exemption from the 2035 post for plug-in hybrids seems, at present, to be a resounding stupidity. Unless we introduce a system (difficult to imagine) to force users to use them in a truly “green” way. More credible, at the limit, is to grant a temporary exemption to “full hybrid” cars. Perhaps accelerating to the maximum – this would really be the most rational and credible solution – the creation of a true ecosystem for electric cars consisting of a solid European industry in the sector, a widespread and efficient charging network and legislation that can limit costly incentives and create a system of genuine convenience.
