La consultation which is of greatest interest in the context of the package of elections that will take place in United States il next 4 November It's not for an elective office. It's not for the election of the mayor of New York, although the list of candidates includes important political figures such as the Democrat Zohran Mamdani, a Ugandan immigrant of Indian descent who has become a symbol of the people the president Donald Trump He would like to ban from the country, as well as – as independents – former governor Andrew Cuomo, forced to resign in 2021 due to sexual harassment allegations, and Eric Adams, the incumbent mayor, already under investigation for corruption before the Justice Department dropped the charges (perhaps in exchange for Adams's commitment not to hinder the raids of illegal immigrants in his jurisdiction).
The races for the title are not even at the centre of political analysis and debate. governorship of Virginia and that of New Jersey, even though the vote falls less than ten months into Trump's second term and the result could therefore be interpreted as a show of confidence or a challenge to what The Donald has done so far, as had already happened in the past with respect to Joe Biden in 2021 and Trump himself in 2017.
What has attracted the attention of political scientists and political commentators, however, is above all the Proposition 50, an popular referendum to be held in California and it concerns the possible redefinition of the colleaguesof this State for theelection of representatives to the Federal House of Representatives in Washington.
Gerrymandering in California
La Proposition 50 It is the Democratic Party's response to the Texas Legislature's decision to redraw the map of its districts for the lower house of Congress in such a way, according to the first simulations of the vote, as to allow the Republican Party to take five seats from the Democratic Party in the mid-term elections (those that take place halfway through a presidential term) of 2026.
Electoral districts are usually redrawn every ten years, immediately after the release of census data. The purpose of these changes is to account for changes in the population of individual states because The seats in the House have been set at 435 since 1929 and are periodically redistributed among the states in proportion, as established by the Constitution, to the size of the resident population. The most recent census was held in 2020, and Texas had already redrawed its districts the following year, following the increase in its representatives from 36 to 38.
Today the Republican Party holds a very narrow majority in the House of Representatives: 219 seats compared to the 213 held by the Democrats (with three vacant due to the resignation or death of elected officials).
The president's political party generally loses votes in midterm elections, as a result of a physiological sense of disappointment and discontent among a portion of its voters towards the occupant of the White House, who almost never manages to keep all the commitments made in the campaign that led him to sit in the Oval Office.
Because of the narrow advantage they enjoy over the Democrats, Republicans risk being left in the minority in the House after next year's elections., a development that would jeopardize the implementation of Trump's legislative agenda.
Therefore, The Donald inducted the Texas legislature, which is responsible for drawing the districts of this state and where Trump supporters have a large majority, to give more strength to his party in view of the 2026 vote, through a geopolitical artifice, known in jargon as gerrymandering (named after the governor of Massachusetts Elbridge Gerry, who in 1812 promulgated the first provision dictated by such a purpose): modifying the territorial structure of the districts to the detriment of the Democrats.
By gaining five additional seats in Texas, Republicans would offset likely losses in other states and thus maintain their majority in the House.
To counteract this strategy the Democratic governor of California, Gavin Newsom, has proposed a popular referendum, precisely Proposition 50, with the aim of drawing a new configuration of the state's districts for the House that would allow an equally artificial growth in his party's seats, so as to offset those he would lose in Texas.
In particular, the proposed change in the districts targets five Republican members (Ken Calvert, Darrell Issa, Kevin Kiley, Doug LaMalfa and David Valadao) who would see some areas predominantly inhabited by conservative voters removed from their current constituencies, and therefore would suffer a significant contraction of their electoral base, or they would have their districts expanded to include areas with a strong progressive presence and therefore would face a considerable increase in Democratic voters who obviously would not be willing to confirm them in Washington.
The Return of Partycracy in the Definition of California's Electoral Colleges
Under the Federal Constitution, electoral law is a matter for the individual states. In Texas, the legislative assembly defines the geographic structure of the districts. and, consequently, their map is subject to the dialectic of the confrontation between the parties and is conditioned by the choices of the political force that is in the majority, today the Republicans.
In California, this task falls to the Citizens Redestricting Commission., a body that took office in 2010. Its members are fourteen: five appointed by the Democratic Party, five by the Republican Party, and four who cannot be linked to a political force, that is, they must be registered as independents on the lists of citizens entitled to vote.
In this way, the Republican and Democratic commissioners are evenly matched in number, while the remaining four members end up making up the difference and should therefore ensure the Citizens Redestricting Commission's independence from party politics. Precisely because of its unique composition, this body would not have been suitable for Newsom's games.
Therefore, The governor proposed and obtained that the state legislature, where Democrats predominate, call a popular referendumProposition 50, which will ask Californians whether they want to temporarily suspend the functions of the Citizens Redestricting Commission for five years and give state legislators the power to draw a new electoral district map—which, in reality, has already been prepared in anticipation of a “yes” victory—exclusively for the 2026, 2028, and 2030 elections.
So, if the “yes” win in November, Districts would be altered to favor Democratic candidates in five districts in 2026 whose seats are currently held by Republicans, but the Citizens Redestricting Commission would resume operation after 2030, the year of the next federal census.
How Referendums Work in California
I popular referendums – both repealing and proposing – are a form of direct democracy that California introduced in 1911 as part of a series of initiatives to give citizens the power to review state policy, to limit the influence that had until then been exerted on legislative provisions by some influential companies of the time, in particular by a large railway trust, the Southern Pacific Railroad.
It is no coincidence that, on the one hand, even if the calling of referendums by the legislative assembly is foreseen, the main way to call them is by collecting signatures on a petition which must be signed by at least 8% of voters for amendments to the Constitution and from 5% for other measures.
On the other hand, to give "a greater voice to the people" the institution of referendums was accompanied by the granting of the vote to women (who would have obtained it at a national level only with the XIX amendment of the Federal Constitution in 1920) and by the recall, that is, by the possibility of obtaining the revocation of an elected official's mandate before its natural expiration, if ousted by a majority of voters.
Newsom himself knows this well, having politically survived a removal attempt in 2021, which was motivated by the accusation of being too lenient in the fight against irregular immigration in the StateOnly 38% of voters voted in favor of his impeachment, a result not particularly surprising considering California's significant Democratic leaning.
What is striking in Proposition 50, however, is the top-down process of the initiative, initiated by the governor and endorsed by the legislative assembly, compared to an instrument that had originally been conceived to ensure citizens greater bottom-up control over the decisions of state institutions.
It may also be surprising that Democrats, after accusing Trump of using redistricting for political purposes in the Texas case, have resorted to the same means. However, as Newsom implicitly justifies, whoever injures by gerrymandering, perishes by gerrymandering.
Moreover, the official name of the measure that allowed the California legislature to pass Proposition 50 is the Election Rigging Response Act, which could be translated as a law in response to the fraudulent manipulation of elections, with a clear reference to what happened in Texas.
Furthermore, one of the first organizations to vote “yes” in the referendum, the California Faculty Association, the union representing university staff in the state, which also includes professors, even justified its position with the need to “fight against fascism.”
Beyond Proposition 50
The most authoritative forecasts agree that the game regarding the reshuffle of the Electoral Colleges will most likely end in a stalemate, that is, that the Republicans will win as many House seats in the districts redrawn to their advantage as they will lose in the new districts drawn to benefit the Democratic candidates.
In light of this likely tie, Newsom's intervention on the structure of California's constituencies has implications that go far beyond the outcome of the 2026 midterm elections. First of all, it is a demonstration of leadership by a politician aiming to run for the White House in 2028.
Not surprisingly, Newsom has already begun practicing the techniques for a future presidential run since December 2023, when he challenged Florida Governor Ron DeSantis in a televised debate broadcast on Fox News. DeSantis was then considered a strong contender for the 2024 Republican nomination before being swept away in the primary elections by Trump's return to the scene.
Newsom then sued Trump over the president's decision to place California National Guard under federal authority and to support it with the Marines to repress protests against the mass deportations of illegal immigrants, which broke out last June, especially in Los Angeles.
Newsom is also having fun ridiculing The Donald making caricatured imitations of them on TikTok.
Furthermore, in a country where participating in elections is particularly expensive (according to a cynical definition by journalist Greg Palast, the United States is “the best democracy that money can buy”), the fundraising for the referendum campaign on Proposition 50, for which an overall cost of around 200 million dollars is estimated, offers Newsom the opportunity to demonstrate his ability to obtain large amounts of funding and to have access to wealthy donors (such as, for example, Reed Hastings, the co-founder of Netflix, who is said to have paid 2 million dollars to the “yes” committee, according to a recent article by Theodore Schleifer, Shane Goldmacher and Laurel Rosenhall for the New York Times).
Finally, California referendums have in the past been an opportunity to make or break the hopes of some prominent White House hopefuls.
The background to the Californian referendums
Proposition 13 of 1978 proposed capping property taxes, requiring a two-thirds majority vote in the state legislature to approve a tax increase, and limiting the revaluation of buildings upon transfer of ownership and expansion.
The referendum was an expression of a fiscal protest against government intervention in the economy, which was deemed excessive. Passed with 62,6% of the vote and supported by former Republican governor Ronald Reagan, who supported its approval, the Proposition 13 opened the doors of the White House for him in the 1980 presidential election.
However, the political outcome was the opposite. Proposition 187 of 1994Faced with the growing presence in California of undocumented immigrants, especially from Mexico and other Central American countries, the referendum called for denying undocumented immigrants access to public education, health care (except for emergency medical care), and other state-provided social services.
Furthermore, with an encouragement to mass denunciation, the Proposition 187 demanded that teachers, principals, doctors, and nursing staff be required to report to federal authorities anyone they came into contact with for work-related reasons who might lead them to suspect that they were undocumented immigrants.
The referendum received 53,9% of the vote in favor, but its provisions did not come into force because they were deemed unconstitutional by a federal district court, not so much for their draconian nature, but because they violated, in favor of one state of the Union, California, the exclusive prerogative of federal institutions to make decisions on immigration matters.
One of the major supporters of Proposition 187 was Pete Wilson, the incumbent Republican governor, who leveraged his support for the referendum to secure a second term in the elections held that same year. Following Reagan's lead, Wilson sought to capitalize on the referendum victory, turning it into a springboard for his candidacy for the White House in 1996.
Unlike Reagan, however, his identification with the package of measures against illegal immigrants proved counterproductive and Wilson was forced to withdraw from the campaign as early as the end of September 1995., even before the Republican primary season for the presidential nomination opened.
Furthermore, thanks in part to the growing number of Hispanics with US citizenship in California, Wilson's xenophobic stance contributed to the state's transformation into a Democratic Party stronghold. Since 1996, a Democratic candidate has consistently won majorities in presidential, Senate, and gubernatorial elections (with the sole exception of Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger's victories in 2003 and 2006).
Additionally, the Democratic Party has consistently held majorities in both houses of the state legislature as well as the delegation to the Washington House of Representatives.
A political laboratory
Even in light of these past referendum consultations, California presents itself as a sort of political laboratory for the futureProposition 50 not only affects the balance of power in the House of Representatives in the final two years of Trump's second term in the White House.
Indeed, despite the possibility of a nationwide gerrymandering tie, if the referendum were to fail, the Democratic Party would be unable to make up for the five seats it is almost certain to lose in Texas.
Newsom's fate is also at stake., who is barred from running for a third term by the State Constitution, and perhaps even by the Democratic Party, which is desperately seeking a viable candidate for the 2028 presidential election after the debacle suffered by Kamala Harris last year.
More generally, the referendum on gerrymandering is becoming a paradigmatic example of the decline of political dialectics in the United StatesTo win elections, changing voting rules to favor one party or a specific candidate increasingly tends to replace the formulation of government programs.
From this perspective, Proposition 50 risks being placed alongside both initiatives such as the limitation of mail-in voting, decided by some Republican-governed states to damage the Democratic Party, and subversive degeneration of electoral democracy.
This second category includes judicial appeals, devoid of any foundation, for alleged Trump-led 2020 election fraud to contest Biden's victory, as well as the attempt to prevent the certification of the Democratic candidate's success not only through the infamous assault on Capitol Hill on January 6, 2021, but also through two resolutions introduced in Congress by some Republican members (and later rejected by the House and Senate) to request the annulment of the votes of the electors of Arizona and Pennsylvania due to irregularities that have never been proven.
For now, the antidote to the likely defeat of the Republican minority's "no" vote on Proposition 50 in the California legislature is another example of geopolitical artifice: the presentation of a unrealistic resolution, paradoxical and unlikely to be approved, which calls for dividing California into two separate states, one made up of the coastal counties, where Democrats prevail, and the other of the inland counties, which tend to be conservative.
. . .
STEFANO LUCONI teaches History of the United States of America in the Department of Historical, Geographical and Ancient Sciences of the University of Padua. His publications include The “Indispensable Nation”. History of the United States from its origins to Trump (2020), US institutions from the drafting of the Constitution to Biden, 1787–2022 (2022), The black soul of the United States. African Americans and the difficult path towards equality, 1619–2023 (2023). The race for the White House 2024. The election of the president of the United States from the primaries to beyond the vote of November 5 (2024).
