Le small Italian banks they have more difficult loans to be collected with respect to large groups, but it's not a question of inefficiency: we need to understand who they finance and why. A recent study by Bank of Italy, signed by Giorgio Meucci, shows that the “less significant” banks (LSIs), i.e. small and medium-sized institutions, support micro and small businesses, the true driving force of the local economy, playing a crucial social and financial role that often escapes statistics.
The social role of small banks in the area
Small and medium-sized institutions show a average rate of bad loans equal to 1,68%, compared to 1,23% for "significant" banks (SI). However, according to the report, this difference is not linked to managerial inefficiency or flawed risk policies, but rather to the economic and social role these banks play in the region.
About 70% of the gap in bad loans it is explained by the features of customers: the LSIs finance mainly micro and small businesses, entities more vulnerable to economic fluctuations and with less liquidity. These businesses are the backbone of Italy's productive fabric, representing 45% of total loans to non-financial companies in the 2021-2024 sample, and their support is crucial for the local economy.
Once the factors related to the size and riskiness of the companies have been isolated, the difference in the quality of credit between large and small institutions it becomes almost nothing, highlighting how small banks operate in a more delicate but professionally managed context.
Higher rates: a consequence of risk, not speculation
Small banks tend to apply higher average rates, with an average spread of 2,22 percentage points compared to 2,03 points for the Si. The study clarifies that this is not a speculative strategy, but the simple consequence of the loan risk profile granted: micro and small businesses, which are more vulnerable, carry a greater risk which is reflected in rates.
When comparing loans with the same risk profile, LSI prices are essentially aligned with those of large banks: the marginal effect of the LSI spread, once all observable characteristics are controlled for, is only 1 basis point. Essentially, LSIs do not penalize riskier customers more than necessary: their margin accurately reflects the real risk.
Financial inclusion: LSIs as access to credit for vulnerable businesses
The Lsi are also distinguished by their greater willingness to grant creditAnalyzing the requests recorded in the Central Credit Register's Initial Information Service (SPI), it emerges that the LSIs approve requests more frequently than the SIs tend to reject them. This is particularly true for very small or start-up businesses.
In effect, small banks act as a "relief valve" for credit, ensuring that even the most vulnerable businesses can access essential financing. Without them, many micro and small businesses would risk being excluded from the credit system.
Apparent risk, real value
The greater riskiness of LSIs is not a defect, but a reflection of their specialization in support the most fragile part of the economy, often overlooked by large banking groups. This role entails greater responsibility, but also a positive impact on the productive fabric: small businesses represent innovation, employment, and local economic resilience, and LSIs are essential to supporting them.
